Skip to navigationSkip to content
BizHanKook BizHanKook

Government Pushes for “Regional Dispersion” While Industry Cries “Discrimination”… The Dilemma of the Data Center ‘75-Point Regulation’

[BizHanKook]  Artificial Intelligence (AI) data centers have emerged as facilities that residents want to avoid in many parts of the United States and Europe. In the U.S., news of a planned data center led residents to flock to local council meetings to oppose its construction. In Ireland, residents and farmers are also raising concerns about increased electricity and water consumption, as well as potential noise pollution. Domestically, residents in various parts of the Seoul metropolitan area are forming countermeasure committees only after learning of construction plans shortly before the groundbreaking.

Amid this situation, the government has begun inducing the construction of data centers in regional areas to reduce the burden on the capital region's power grid. Under new regulations implemented by the Ministry of Climate, Environment and Energy on November 16, data centers built in the capital region must score 75 points on the power system impact assessment, which is 5 points higher than for general industries. 

The data center industry is pushing back, questioning the equity compared to other industries and the validity of non-technical evaluation criteria beyond electricity. Meanwhile, civil society demands that, beyond location regulations, there should be disclosure of data center-related information and the integration of renewable energy standards. Will raising the threshold for the capital region drive data centers to regional areas? If the locations shift, how should the conflicts surrounding electricity and water usage be resolved?

The government has strengthened regulations regarding the power system impact assessment for data centers in the Seoul metropolitan area to resolve power grid overloads and disperse data centers to non-capital regions. Photo = Reporter Park Jung-hoon

The power system impact assessment is a system that verifies in advance the impact that large-scale power demand has on surrounding power grids and the environment during the planning stage, based on the 'Special Act on the Promotion of Distributed Energy.' After the special act went into effect in June 2024, it underwent a pilot operation starting in August of the same year, and with this latest notification, a legal framework including evaluation targets, criteria, and scoring standards has been established. During the pilot period, 28 cases (1.9GW) were submitted for the capital region and 64 cases (7GW) for non-capital regions, showing a trend of decreasing density in the capital area.

In this notification, the Ministry of Climate established a new category for power consumption density, deducting 5 points if located in a zone where power usage exceeds standard values. Conversely, 5 points are added if a site provides new transmission lines or substations in non-capital regions, contributing to securing power supply capacity.

Mechanisms to block dummy applicants have also been set up. To filter out applicants aiming to preempt power grid capacity without actual intent to proceed with business or financing plans, the transfer of deliberation result notifications to third parties is prohibited, and the validity period is limited to 1 year from the date of issuance (renewable once for up to 1 year). In particular, because data centers in the capital region are operated under constant high loads and have a significant impact on the power system, the passing score was set higher than the 70 points required for general industries, at 75 points.

Lee Jae-sik, Director of Power Grid Policy at the Ministry of Climate, stated, "This notification will help with balanced national development and stable operation of the power system by strengthening assessments on power grid impact and increasing incentives for businesses located in regions with abundant electricity," adding, "We will operate a specialized deliberation system and procedures for the power system impact assessment to ensure that the related regulations are firmly established in the field."

Manpower and Infrastructure Concentrated in the Capital… Industry Backlash

Data center power consumption is on the rise along with the expansion of the AI industry. The reason demand has concentrated in the capital region lies in the characteristics of location and industrial structure. The colocation (server rental) business, which hosts and manages client servers, requires proximity to the Seoul outskirts where many client engineers work to access and maintain equipment. Companies prefer the capital region to minimize network latency and respond quickly to maintenance needs. Services sensitive to network delays as small as 0.001 seconds (1 millisecond), such as finance and gaming, have also fueled demand for locations in the capital area.

Operating personnel and infrastructure conditions are also cited as causes for this concentration. The capital region is well-equipped with power and communication networks and makes it easy to secure professional staff for 24/7 operations. In contrast, regional areas have the weakness that even if there is surplus power generation, it takes time and money to connect the power grid, water supply, and communication networks to the actual data center site.

The industry is protesting the government's application of a high 75-point standard only to data centers in the capital region. They argue it is discriminatory compared to other power-intensive industries, especially since businesses in national high-tech strategic industries like semiconductors are exempt from the power system impact assessment.

Furthermore, they question the structure of evaluating non-technical criteria that are unrelated to power system stability, such as a company's equity ratio, credit rating (business stability), expected local tax payments over the next 20 years, and job creation effects. Critics point out that the procedure of estimating and submitting future revenue and employment figures before the project begins does not align with the realities on the ground.

A data center industry official said, "We are disappointed and concerned that the notification was implemented with almost no changes despite us conveying our opinions and worries through various channels."

Civil Society: “Policy Standards Need Supplementation”

While agreeing with the government's fundamental direction of resolving power density in the capital area and dispersing data centers to regional areas, civil society points out that blind spots in the system need to be addressed. Currently, the power system impact assessment applies to facilities with a contract power of 10MW or more. There is no control mechanism to prevent the loophole where the same operator splits a facility into segments under 10MW to avoid the criteria.

The lack of renewable energy integration standards is also cited as a limitation. Germany has legally mandated that data center companies use 100% renewable energy starting in 2027. In contrast, domestic policy focuses only on incentives for regional locations without mandating renewable energy use, leading to concerns that even if data centers are dispersed to regional areas, the increase in fossil fuel power generation (such as LNG) could ultimately lead to higher greenhouse gas emissions.

Local resident acceptance and information transparency are also under scrutiny. In various parts of the capital region, residents only learned of data center construction plans near the start of construction, leading them to form committees in opposition. Although complaints are rising at the local government level, there is a lack of legal standards to manage or control construction. Civil society emphasizes that a system for periodically disclosing metrics such as electricity and water usage should accompany the process, going beyond one-time disclosures at the construction stage.

Lee Sun-mi, a team leader at the People's Solidarity for Participatory Democracy's Policy Planning Bureau, said, "Until now, data centers have sprung up without guidelines simply because the public was unfamiliar with the facilities," adding, "It is time to establish policy standards that include not only location regulations but also the disclosure of electricity and water usage information and principles for renewable energy."

Kim Minho

Covers the heavy chemical and energy industries. Deeply interested in sustainable living and a sustainable society.

goldmino@bizhankook.com
Copyright © BizHanKook. All rights reserved.