Skip to navigationSkip to content
BizHanKook BizHanKook

'GTA6' Cleared: How South Korea Became a Country More Lenient Toward Games

[BizHanKook] There was a time when South Korea blocked the domestic distribution of 'Mortal Kombat' due to its brutal scenes. It did not even provide a path for the game to be sold exclusively to adults, surpassing the "Not for Youth" (18+) rating. Fifteen years later, South Korea has become the most lenient country in Asia regarding the portrayal of content in adult-oriented games. This is because 'GTA6', which contains nudity and intense depictions of violence, has been released without any modifications.

The highly anticipated global release 'Grand Theft Auto 6 (GTA6)' is set for its official launch on the 19th with an 18+ rating. While there were initial concerns that the game might be denied classification due to nudity and intense violence, its domestic distribution was ultimately approved. This is interpreted as a reflection of the growing trend to recognize games as a form of cultural art, while the scope of permitted expression in adult-oriented games continues to widen.

'Grand Theft Auto 6 (GTA6)' has received an 18+ rating and is set to be released on the 19th. Domestic distribution was approved in consideration of the fact that the nudity itself is not necessarily intended for sexual stimulation and that users cannot directly engage in sexual interactions in those specific scenes. Photo = Provided by Rockstar Games

GTA6 Overcomes Refusal of Rating... Beyond Levels of Expression, Context Is Now Considered

The Game Content Rating Board (GCRB) under the Game Culture Foundation granted an 18+ rating to GTA6 on the 16th of last month. In the first review, the opinions were split between 18+ and a refusal of classification (3 votes each), and the decision was subsequently postponed twice. In the third review, the final decision was 8 votes for 18+ and 1 vote for refusal of classification.

During the review process, opinions were divided over the fact that nudity appears repeatedly in scenes unrelated to sexual acts. However, the committee considered that the nudity itself was not necessarily intended for sexual arousal and that users could not directly engage in sexual interactions within those scenes.

While an 18+ rating allows adults to access a game, a refusal of classification effectively restricts the official domestic distribution of the game. If the depictions of violence or sexual content are deemed excessive, even adults are prevented from playing the game.

In nearby Japan, the game received a 'CERO Z' rating, which is restricted to ages 18 and up. The Japanese version of the previous game, 'GTA5', was released with some violent depictions of torture reduced, and attention is now focused on whether the expressions in the Japanese version of this title have been altered. In mainland China, where official government approval is required to sell foreign games, there is no precedent for the GTA series, including 'GTA6', receiving sales approval. In Europe, the game was given a 'PEGI 18' rating due to drugs, sexual expression, and extreme violence. South Korea, which had considered a refusal of classification, ultimately allowed the release for adults, just as in Europe.

'Cyberpunk 2077', released in 2020, also included nudity and violent scenes but was allowed to be distributed domestically as an adult game. 'GTA5', the predecessor to GTA6, also received an 18+ rating despite containing various harmful elements such as crime, violence, and drugs. With GTA6 also overcoming the crisis of a classification refusal, the evaluation is that a new standard has emerged regarding how far the sexuality and violence of adult games will be permitted and how the review criteria are changing.

Games Adults Cannot Play... The Regulatory Framework Established After 'Sea Story'

For a long time, game reviews in South Korea have focused on youth protection, preventing gambling, and maintaining social order. One of the catalysts for strengthening this regulatory framework was the 'Sea Story' incident in 2006. Sea Story was an arcade game that caused social controversy as it was effectively used as a gambling tool, allowing players to exchange prizes won through the game for cash.

As loopholes in game review and prize-giving systems were exposed, the demand to manage gambling games and block illegal distribution grew. The Game Rating and Administration Committee (GRAC) was launched in October of that year, establishing a system responsible for judging gambling, classification, and distribution management.

Subsequently, the reboot of 'Mortal Kombat' released in 2011 was denied a rating by the GRAC due to its brutality. At the time, the GRAC determined that the violent imagery, sound, and excessive depictions of mutilation and blood were highly likely to cause social concern. Despite the publisher's attempts at re-review, the official domestic release was scrapped. 'Mortal Kombat 11', released in 2019, also failed to pass domestic review due to its intense violence. The 'Fatality' finishing moves, where characters dismember or mutilate their opponents, were the primary issue.

On the other hand, there are games that have been allowed to be released domestically despite containing brutal violent depictions. 'Dead Rising 2', released in 2010, is a game involving brutal combat against zombies but received an 18+ rating. The compilation version of the early 'Mortal Kombat' series was also classified as 18+ despite including scenes of mutilation.

The controversy over the consistency of standards continued as review results varied among games containing similar levels of brutal scenes. In particular, criticism of so-called "rubber-band reviews" (inconsistent standards) was raised because it was difficult for developers and users to predict whether a game could be distributed domestically based on publicly available criteria.

Amid ongoing controversy over the consistency of the GRAC's game review criteria, the Game Content Rating Board (GCRB), a private organization under the Game Culture Foundation, has been responsible for classifying 18+ PC and console games since November of last year. Photo = Yonhap News

How Far Does Expression Go in Adult Games... Changing Review Criteria

According to the gaming industry, from November of last year to April of this year, the GCRB granted 18+ ratings to 44 games. In May, the first case of a classification refusal since the transition to the private agency occurred due to excessively explicit nudity and sexual acts. However, even that game was eventually allowed for distribution after the problematic scenes were modified, leading to an 18+ rating.

Previously, the GCRB had been responsible for classifying All-Ages, 12+, and 15+ PC and console games since 2014, but since November of last year, it has also taken over the classification tasks for 18+ PC and console games, which were previously exclusively handled by the GRAC. From the 2nd of this month, the scope of its duties expanded to include 18+ mobile games.

Changes are also appearing in social perceptions of games. While past gaming policies focused on youth addiction or blocking harmful content, the cultural enjoyment and content choices of adult users are increasingly being highlighted as important considerations.

In fact, according to the Korea Creative Content Agency, the percentage of people who have used games in the past year is 85.1% for those in their 20s, 74.4% for their 30s, 60.7% for their 40s, and 44.6% for their 50s. As game usage occurs across the entire adult population, determining how to guarantee the choices of adult users, beyond just protecting youth, has become an important issue.

Institutional changes recognizing games as a form of cultural art are also underway. The Culture and Arts Promotion Act, amended in 2022, explicitly included games in the definition of culture and art. Following the implementation of this law in March 2023, games are legally recognized as a field of culture and art, alongside literature, film, and music. A legal foundation has been established to recognize the value of creation and expression, moving away from viewing games solely as entertainment or a subject for regulation.

Yun Chae-hyun

I cover the telecommunications, platform, and content industries. My goal is to make complex topics easy and engaging to read.

coguszz@bizhankook.com
Copyright © BizHanKook. All rights reserved.