Skip to navigationSkip to content
BizHanKook BizHanKook

Bithumb Affiliate Stock Manipulation and Embezzlement Case: 'Verdict' to be Reached After 4 Years

[BizHanKook] The first-instance court verdict regarding the stock manipulation, embezzlement, and breach of trust case involving Kang Jong-hyun, who was at the center of the Bithumb "de facto owner" controversy, is set to be delivered. This comes approximately four years after the case was indicted. Mr. Kang also recently received a confirmed suspended sentence in the Bithumb coin listing solicitation case. Vidente and Bucket Studio, which were targets of the stock manipulation, have faced trading suspensions and the threat of delisting, leaving minority shareholders to bear the losses. As the damages to minority shareholders have persisted for a long time, attention is focused on how the court will determine the responsibility of the defendants, including Mr. Kang.

The first-instance court verdict for the stock manipulation, embezzlement, and breach of trust case involving Mr. Kang Jong-hyun (pictured), who stood at the center of the Bithumb "de facto owner" controversy, will be delivered after four years. Photo = Yonhap News

It has been confirmed that the first-instance trial regarding the stock manipulation, breach of trust, and embezzlement surrounding Bithumb affiliates is nearing its sentencing phase. The 12th Criminal Division of the Seoul Southern District Court has designated February 13, 2027, at 2:00 PM as the sentencing date for the case. This is about four years after the case was filed in February 2023.

The Bithumb affiliate stock manipulation case centers on allegations that Mr. Kang Jong-hyun, who sparked the Bithumb "de facto owner" controversy, manipulated the stock prices of KOSDAQ-listed companies such as Vidente, Bucket Studio, and Inbiogen between 2020 and 2022 to reap approximately 35 billion won in unfair profits. Mr. Kang's group is also accused of embezzling 62.8 billion won in funds from Bithumb affiliates between 2020 and 2022.

This case involves businessman Kang Jong-hyun, his younger sister Kang Ji-yeon, CEO of Bucket Studio, Initial, and Inbiogen, and Won Young-sik, CEO of Ocean In The W (former chairman of Chorokbaem Group). CEO Won is accused of providing funds during the stock manipulation process and, alongside the Kang siblings, obtaining unfair profits through the trading of convertible bonds (CB) of Vidente and Bucket Studio.

The damages from the stock manipulation, embezzlement, and breach of trust fell squarely on the minority shareholders. As the volume of shares increased due to CB issuance, stock prices plummeted, and companies like Vidente and Bucket Studio have been under trading suspension for years amid allegations that listed company funds were used for the private interests of external forces. Vidente and Bucket Studio are pursuing a sale to implement improvements in corporate governance through the sale of management rights. Last October, the American financial firm NMSI emerged as a new buyer and paid the down payment.

The final hearing for the case was held on September 18, and the prosecution demanded a 20-year prison sentence, a 150 billion won fine, and the forfeiture of 18.1 billion won for Mr. Kang Jong-hyun on charges including fraudulent unfair trading under the Capital Markets Act, embezzlement, and breach of trust. The prosecution demanded 7 years in prison for CEO Kang Ji-yeon, and 15 years in prison, a 300 billion won fine, and the forfeiture of approximately 2.4 billion won for CEO Won Young-sik. For Mr. Cho, a representative of a Vidente affiliate who was indicted together, 6 years in prison was requested, and 5 years in prison each was requested for two employees.

A conclusion was also recently reached in the Bithumb coin listing solicitation case in which Mr. Kang was involved. The coin listing solicitation case is an event from 2021 where Mr. Kang Jong-hyun provided money and valuables to professional golfer Ahn Sung-hyun and former Bithumb Holdings CEO Lee Sang-jun, requesting that two types of coins be listed on Bithumb. Mr. Kang was accused of providing 3 billion won in cash, two Patek Philippe watches worth 400 million won, luxury bags, and high-end restaurant memberships in exchange for the coin listings. They were indicted without detention in September 2023.

Regarding the case where Mr. Kang Jong-hyun and others solicited the listing of two types of coins on the KRW-based virtual asset exchange Bithumb, former Bithumb Holdings CEO Lee Sang-jun received a sentence of 2 years in prison suspended for 3 years. Photo = Reporter Park Jung-hoon

On the 12th, the Second Division of the Supreme Court dismissed the prosecution's appeal regarding the four individuals including Mr. Kang and confirmed the lower court's ruling. For Mr. Kang Jong-hyun, a sentence of 1 year in prison suspended for 2 years was confirmed on charges of bribery for breach of trust. The acquittal in the first and second trials for an investor named Mr. Song, who was accused of bribery for breach of trust for asking Mr. Kang to list the coins, was upheld.

Former CEO Lee Sang-jun was indicted on charges of taking bribes for breach of trust, and a sentence of 2 years in prison suspended for 3 years was confirmed. The court also ordered Mr. Lee to pay a forfeiture of 11,525,000 won. Professional golfer Ahn Sung-hyun, who was indicted together, was charged with fraud and taking bribes for breach of trust under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes, but was ultimately acquitted.

In Mr. Lee's case, the charges of receiving watches, luxury bags, and restaurant memberships worth 260 million won in exchange for listing solicitation were recognized. The court determined that "taking bribes for breach of trust" applies because Mr. Lee was in a position to influence the listing review even if he did not conduct the review himself. Bithumb Holdings is the holding company and largest shareholder (73.56%) of Bithumb. Former CEO Lee received a 2-year prison sentence in the first trial, but was given a 2-year prison sentence suspended for 3 years in the second trial due to mitigating factors such as returning the watches before the investigation began, which was confirmed on the 12th.

The second-instance court pointed out regarding former CEO Lee, "Unjust coin listings hinder the sound development of the virtual asset market, disturb market order, and can cause enormous financial losses to innocent investors," adding, "Despite having a special social responsibility in light of the public nature of the exchange, (Mr. Lee) denied all public charges and did not show an attitude of remorse." However, the court considered mitigating factors such as the fact that the two coins Mr. Kang solicited for listing were not actually listed on Bithumb, that Mr. Lee did not actively demand compensation, and that he is a first-time offender.

Mr. Kang Jong-hyun, who solicited the listing of the two coins on Bithumb, was sentenced to 1 year and 6 months in prison in the first trial, but his sentence was reduced to 1 year in prison suspended for 2 years in the second trial. Mr. Kang had planned to provide money and valuables to former CEO Lee Sang-jun and others to solicit the listing, and then artificially pump the price after the listing to dispose of them. However, he received a reduced sentence based on reasons such as acknowledging the criminal facts and the fact that the actual coin listing failed. The charges of taking bribes for breach of trust related to Mr. Ahn Sung-hyun were also acquitted.

In Mr. Ahn's case, he received a 4-year and 6-month prison sentence in the first trial, but it was overturned to an acquittal in the second trial. The court determined that unlike former CEO Lee Sang-jun, Mr. Ahn was not a recipient of bribes for breach of trust. The second and third courts viewed Mr. Ahn as closer to being a party who delivered the solicitation on behalf of Mr. Kang rather than an accomplice who received the proceeds of the solicitation together with former CEO Lee.

Shim Jiyoung

I cover the finance, cryptocurrency, fintech, and investment sectors. Please feel free to reach out with any tips.

jyshim@bizhankook.com
Copyright © BizHanKook. All rights reserved.