[BizHanKook] As the song “Have You Become the Adult You Dreamed Of,” known to be created by AI, secured the No. 1 spot on the Melon chart for consecutive days, opinions have been divided. This wasn’t simply a debate about the pros and cons of AI-generated music. It drew even more attention because AI songs have been dominating the charts, outperforming currently prominent idol groups like A2O Light’s “Neon,” Rescene’s “With,” and ILLIT’s “I’ll Arrest You.” The fact that it reached No. 1 without the influence of an already established, powerful K-pop fandom is considered extraordinary.
Moreover, this is even more notable because it didn't just appear out of nowhere to hit the top spot, but climbed steadily to the top while fluctuating within the upper ranks. This indicates that the results are likely not due to chart manipulation (abusing). In fact, it showed more stability than cases where idol music rises to No. 1 only to fall sharply, suggesting a solid, genuine listener base. This is what made it different from previous AI songs.

Initially, regardless of location, preferences for AI-produced songs have tended to change before and after knowing their origin. Usually, people say they like a song before finding out it was made by AI, but once they do, they often show aversion. Some even feel disgusted with themselves for feeling sincere emotions from an AI song, or feel humiliated at the thought of being swayed by something "fake." The dislike for AI songs could stem from feelings of regret over a choice made under a misconception.
In terms of content production, “Have You Become the Adult You Dreamed Of” differs from other AI-utilized songs. It was not cobbled together by an amateur. The song’s production team, ‘Glory Wave,’ is composed of composer and producer Lee Yong-seok (Martin East) and Choi Seong-hyeok (Beatjaru), who have already created many popular hits. In other words, they are musicians who well understand what songs people enjoy and what can become popular.
Furthermore, they had mastered the method of using AI to compose music. The AI musician ‘MEOMURU’ is a virtual vocalist, but the lyrics were written by a human. They grasped how to make the melody and lyrics blend well with the vocals and blended them effectively. This is why the song is perceived as a calculated, intentional effort. The entire process—from planning and melody composition to editing and vocal adjustment—was meticulously managed. It was this level of control and direction that enabled its popularity.
The important point is that the success of this song is not just the achievement of the AI-utilizing production team. Numerous listeners who heard the track shared their personal stories in the comments section, which in turn created an effect of attracting new listeners. Although the AI vocalist is not human, the stories in the comments are experiences that people have actually lived. The lyrics about not becoming the adult one envisioned as a child, paired with an emotional, retro melody, became a factor that gathered people in their 30s and 40s. In reality, it is extremely difficult for any song—AI-created or human-created—to become a hit. Even in K-pop, which is known for its easy formulas, it is not easy to gauge success in the top ranks without a powerful fandom.
There were precursors to the preference for AI songs. The virtual idol PLAVE is a prime example. Although PLAVE is a virtual idol, they formed a fandom and gained consistent popularity. Two factors influenced this: the level of their songs was excellent, and they met the tastes of their fans. If it aligns with their tastes, there is less resistance to choosing and accepting a virtual idol or character.
The remaining task for the future is sustainability. The question is whether the songs released by the production team ‘Glory Wave’ through ‘MEOMURU’ will continue to receive a positive response. Whether a fandom can form, much like with virtual idols, is also a key point. In the case of PLAVE, mutual feedback strengthened the fandom. Moreover, since PLAVE uses human voices, there is a sense of human warmth. Conversely, “Have You Become the Adult You Dreamed Of” is so perfect that it can feel alienating if listened to repeatedly. The advantage and disadvantage of AI content is that it is too smooth. Humans are defined by their flaws, which often evoke a sense of familiarity.
Above all, a more practical generation is on the rise. If something aligns with their tastes, they don't care if it's AI or human. All that matters is that it is authentic, relatable, and human-like content that speaks for them. As AI technology is poised to reflect even this, human singers are inevitably being spurred to survive. It is clear that the effort to emphasize human charm through distinct imperfections, rather than striving for perfection, will be strengthened.
The author Kim Heon-sik has been wandering through or cutting through the forest of pop culture phenomena since his 20s, with the expectation that there is a way to make the world a better place through culture. He continues on the same path with the same belief even in the 21st century, where artificial intelligence and quantum computers are active.